CHAPTER V METHODS OF SUGGESTION AND HYPNOTISM
Suggestibility is the characteristic of all human beings, but
there are methods which increase that suggestibility.
Suggestion has been used largely for the cure of various mental
disorders and physical ailments, formerly chiefly by inducing the hypnotic
state, getting the subject to actual sleep, nowadays in its newest form by
direct suggestion in the waking state. "We put the subject in a condition
of objective passiveness by rest of the brain and relaxation of the muscles,
thus producing a state akin to the mental and bodily state preceding natural
sleep.
For medical purposes we aim at that early stage of sleep that is
consistent with consciousness—a transsitional stage which anyone who has
analysed his sensations has recognised as a brief period immediately preceding
the unconsciousness of slumber, when by an effort he can become wide-awake, or
by lying still and guarding his mind against exciting thoughts can insure
speedy and perfect sleep.
The room in which hypnotism is practised should be quiet, should contain
nothing which captivates the attention too much, and gives rise to either
emotion or constraint. With respect to witnesses, at all events at first, the
number should be limited as far as circumstances and propriety will warrant.
The patient lying down on a couch or seated in a lounging chair, in
which he has a comfortable rest for his head, the first step is to induce in
the patient a mental state of calm and relaxation; a mental state which causes
the patient to become receptive to the impressions that we wish to make upon his
or her mind. The best plan is to have the patient seat himself in a comfortable
position, and then talk to him a little to remove his fears and in order to
induce a placid, easy frame of mind, which will react upon the physical
conditions. He is asked to resign himself, not think of anything, not to
distract bis mind by thinking of the effects he will experience, to banish
every fear, and not be uneasy or discouraged if he fall not asleep at once. He
is then told to concentrate his attention upon sleep, to try to go to sleep;
and, to assist him in this effort by preventing his taking in distracting ideas
through his eyes as they wander around the room and see the pictures, books and
furniture, we may get him to fix his gaze upon some bright and shining object.
Thus, fixity of attention, passivity and concentration are produced. He is
instructed not to try to keep his eyes open, and not to close them voluntarily,
but merely to let the lids go as they will. The physician may now keep quiet
for a time, or else by a monotonous talk he may encourage the patient in his
effort to go to sleep. Personally, I never employ authority, but talk
sympathetically, using my own earnest efforts to make an impression.
The passive state simply means the suspension of the functions of the
conscious state of mind for the time being, for the purpose of allowing the
subconscious
mind to receive impressions and to act upon them. The more perfectly the
objective intelligence can be held in abeyance, the more perfectly will the
subconscious self be reached, influenced, and perform its functions.
No suggestion should be made, unless the patient is really in a
perfectly passive state, or has actually gone to sleep. "We may test him
by commanding him "to open his eyes, if he can," when probably he
will be already unable to raise his lids. If we now raise his arm it will drop,
as if not attached to his body.
Suggestions referring to his ailment may now be made, speaking plainly
and emphatically. In the case of minor mental disorders and morbid habits, we
can now impress the patient with a desire to break himself of the morbid idea
or impulse, and, by calling his own powers of thought and volition into play,
we may get him to recognise his delusions, if any, and feel confident the he
really will be able to control himself.
Such is the modern method of inducing the proper state for suggestive
treatment, which has been found to suffice for all practical purposes. Sleep
need not be induced, but only the somnolent state. This method has the advantage
that nearly everybody can be subjected to it. But the deeper the hypnotic state
the more prompt will be the cure, and that is a consideration for many people.
The suggestibility of persons varies, of course, a great deal. Some are
more susceptible, and may at once fall asleep, in which case they may be
allowed to sleep, making the suggestion that on waking the symptoms they
complain of will be gone.
In others, because of the severity of the symptoms from which they
suffer, or for other reasons—as, for instance, in order to study the phenomena
of hypnotism in subjects who volunteer for scientific purposes-it may be
desirable to produce the deeper state. For the deeper states not all persons
are suitable, because they lack the required susceptibility. In others, again,
a conscious or subconscious contrary auto-suggestion will retard or prevent
deep hypnosis.
The induction of the somnolent state is a fairly simple process; the
induction of the deeper state of hypnosis is more difficult, and generally
requires more continued application. But in all cases, hypnotism for medical
treatment is more readily induced than for any other purpose, because in the
sick the voluntary and conscious activity is diminished by exhaustion, and they
are really earnest about it in order to get cured.
A good preliminary test whether a person can be hypnotised is to judge
his sensibility by drawing the palm of the hand downwards, without contact, but
very near, over his face or hands, best while the eyes are closed, when it will
be found that some subjects perceive a peculiar sensation, from mere warmth to
pricking, and in the most susceptible a sensation as if a mild electric current
passed over their skin. This used to be described as the magnetic influence,
and although no such influence is admitted now, I have always found that these
passes were felt more readily and by more persons when I had been doing much
hypnotic work, than when I had rested for some time.
Another test of a person's susceptibility is by standing behind him and
making long passes from the back
of the head down to the end of the spine. A large proportion of persons
will at once feel an inclination to sway backwards.
"The old mesmerists used to get their subjects to look steadily at
their eyes while they gazed at them firmly and made slow passes with one or
both hands downwards from the crown of the patient's head, over the face to the
pit of the stomach, or even down to the feet, always avoiding contact. After
each pass the hands were well shaken, just as if something were shaken off
them. The passes would be continued, patiently, for some time,'until they
excited the sensation of warmth, pricking or tingling, or numbness, according
to the individual operated on. Or else the magnetiser would sit down close by
the patient, take hold of his thumbs, and gently pressing them gaze fixedly in
his eyes, concentrating his mind upon him, while the subject would gaze at the
operator. The gaze of the subject had the effect of concentrating his
attention, and the look of the operator, so to say, commanded him not to
"wander" in his thoughts. The old magnetisers laid the greatest
stress on the intense concentration on the part of the operator, and would
achieve success often by intent gazing alone, without passes or verbal suggestion.
At public performances magnetisers used soft strains of music, which
appeared to assist greatly the induction of sleep in new subjects.
In my experience, the gazing process cannot be employed by everyone. It
requires in the person who employs it a sharp, penetrating look, capable of
long-continued fixedness; it will likewise seldom succeed on individuals who
are magnetised for the first time.
The magnetisers, when they had made the passes downwards for some time,
looking at the patients and not finding them yielding to their influence, would
close the patients' eyes, and press the fingers gently on the eyelids and
retain them there for a few minutes, at the same time concentrating all their
efforts. This method succeeds with some patients better than the continual
stare.
Stroking the skin of the brow and temples is another way of producing
the same effect.
Another method is to hold two fingers before the subject's eyes, and ask
him to gaze at their tips and to concentrate his attention on the idea of sleep.
The fingers are moved from a distance close to the eyes and away again, when
the tiring effect of constant accommodation of vision often produces the
desired effect.
A more modern method to produce these sensations and subsequent hypnosis
is by gazing, on the part of the patient alone, either at a small object in his
hand, or at an object placed above and before the eyes, as was done with
success by Braid, of whom we shall learn more presently. The object was held
close in order to cause convergence of the eyes.
Later, Braid gave up placing the object so close as to cause
convergence. He found it advantageous to hold the object so high that the
eyelids are strained as much as possible in keeping the eyes open.
Still later, Braid found that fixed gazing was frequently followed by
discomfort in the eyes. Thereupon he abandoned the prolonged gazing, and
instructed! the patient to close his eyes at an early stage
of the proceedings. Hypnosis was induced as easily as before, and the
unpleasant symptoms disappeared. Provided the body and mind were at rest, he
found he could hypnotise as readily in the dark as in the light.
The simplest process, though applicable only to selected cases, is to
leave the subject seated by himself, telling him that if he close his eyes and
relax his muscles, and, as far as possible, think of "nothing," he
will fall asleep. Then the operator may leave the room, and on returning after
a time he sometimes finds the patient fast asleep.
Most physicians use the modern method (Bernheim's method) of persuasion
and suggestion: inducing sleep by describing to the patient the successive
stages of sleep, "your eyelids are getting heavy, you are getting tired,
you can hardly keep your eyes open, they are closing now," and so on.
This method is, however, not so new as is claimed by some, for it is
only a variation, or rather a more detailed application of the process employed
by the Abbe Faria, a magnetiser who performed his experiments as a public
showman, and was considered a quack in his days. But no one can deny that he
was eminently successful.
He placed in a chair the person who wished to submit himself to his
manipulation, recommended him to shut his eyes, and, after adjusting himself
for some minutes, said to him in a loud and commanding' voice, "Sleep!"
This simple word, uttered in the midst of solemn silence by a man whose
wonderous feats were so much spoken of, made sometimes on the patient an
impression sufficiently intense to produce the phenomena of hypnotism and
somnambulism.
Some physicians do not scrapie to use narcotics to induce hypnotism,
but, in my opinion, the use of them is to be condemned.
Persons can be hypnotised, too, while in their normal sleep. The method
is to repeat in a gentle voice, " Sleep, sleep, go on sleeping!" when it will
be found that, after a time, rapport is established between the sleeping
person and the operator, and questions will be answered. Some stroke the
patient gently while commanding him to sleep. This method is considered of much
practical value in subduing persons who otherwise make difficult subjects.
Any of these methods may be tried, and sometimes have to be, for some
persons are more impressionable to one than the other. Some get distracted when
they are touched, while others go off more easily when they feel the contact of
the operator. As a matter of fact, all processes succeed when they inspire
confidence in the subject.
As a rule, each hypnotiser has his own pet method, but the real expert
is able to judge the mental susceptibility of the subject at first sight, and
can tell at once what process would be most successful.
Some hypnotists declare that they can hypnotise 90 per cent, of all
comers; others say only 20 per cent., or even less. The difference is to be
accounted for by the fact that the one who derives such a great success induces
only the somnolent state, which is all that is necessary for most cases,
whereas the other is not satisfied unless he can produce actual hypnosis.
It will be noticed that though all the methods vary, the conditions to
produce hypnosis are practically the same:
1. First and foremost is that of fixation of the
attention.
2. Monotonous environment,
to produce monotony
of impressions and intellectual drowsiness, the prelude of sleep.
3. Limitation of voluntary
movements by relaxation of the muscles.
4. Limitation of the field
of consciousness by allowing no new incoming impressions, and
5. Inhibition of ideas by
making the mind as near
as possible a perfect blank.
Much also depends on the personal magnetism, sympathy, or authority of
the operator, and much on his tact in interpretating the susceptibility of the
patient, employing the right process and giving the right suggestions.
The operator grows more successful the more he operates. Still, it must
be said that the condition of hypnosis lies in the mind of the subject himself;
the experimenter has no power except as the subject gives him power. The
subject comes to the doctor prepared for hypnotisation, and he makes conditions
easy for its attainment.
"Women, as a rule, are more susceptible than men, because in them
the feelings are stronger; they are by nature more passive, have greater
sensibility, more tendency to the marvellous, more veneration, a livelier
faith, less cerebro-spinal or voluntary energy, and a more highly developed
sympathetic nervous system.
I'am, of course, referring to normal subjects all the time. Hysterical
patients can sometimes be thrown immediately into hypnotic catalepsy by any
violent sensation, such as by striking a gong or the flashing of
an intense light in their eyes. Pressure on certain parts of the body,
oftenest found on the forehead and about the root of the thumbs, rapidly
produces hypnotic sleep in some hysterics.
Owing to the fact that hypnotism is nowadays practised chiefly by
physicians and for medical purposes, the notion is common that only sick
people, or people suffering from nervous or other disorders, can be hypnotised.
This is a mistake, however; perfectly healthy people make equally excellent
subjects, as will be made clear to the reader in subsequent chapters; only
healthy people have no reason to consult a doctor. The mistaken notion that
only hysterical or nervous patients are susceptible to hypnotism results from
the fact that such people come more under the observation of physicians.
Nor has weakness of "will" anything to do with the
susceptibility of a subject. What hinders hypnotisation sometimes is
"mental pre-occupation," which, however, may suddenly at some moment
be removed.
Neither is it lack of muscular strength that predisposes to hypnosis:
strong muscular persons are equally easily hypnotised if the conditions
enumerated are fulfilled. If they are not, even the feeblest person will make a
bad subject.
Nor are "credulous" persons necessarily good subjects. There
are plenty of people who believe all that they are told, yet they often offer a
lively resistance when an effort is made to hypnotise them.
Insane people are notoriously hard to hypnotise, because of the
difficulty to engage their attention and get them to concentrate. But with persons in the
primary stages of mental disorder—that is to say, not altogether
mad—there is no such difficulty.
I believe I am the first to draw attention to the fact that there are
many people who hypnotise themselves constantly, without being aware of it. I
do not mean men who get so "lost" by concentration on their thoughts
or work—the brown study—that they do not notice what is going on around them,
but rather persons who get" vacant," thinking of nothing in particular. I
have come across many such subjects, recognised by the peculiar stare of their
eyes, and found those who have consented to let me try them excellent subjects
for the production of the higher phenomena of the hypnotic state. Others I have
had as patients, and, needless to say, there was no necessity for me to
hypnotise them; they produced the state themselves when I drew their attention
to what I had observed in them. One or two consultations suffice for such
people to cure them of their disorder.
It is entirely possible to hypnotise oneself. Most of us have, at times,
let ourselves go mentally until we were on the verge of what seemed to be a
kind of fascination or trance, at the brink of which we aroused ourselves with
a start. If now we place ourselves under circumstances favourable to sleep,
cutting off, so far as may be, actual impressions, and attend concentratedly to
the idea of hypnosis, we presently drop into a similar state of
"fascination," which soon becomes hypnosis proper, and, later, passes
off as ordinary sleep. This self-hypnotisation, which can be facilitated by
looking intently at a reflected light or some other subject, is useful to
persons suffering from insomnia.
|